So Monday morning I get ready for work, as I'm walking out the door I decide to peek in the basement just to make sure everything was ok.
Good thing I did because there was an inch or two of water, the pump wasn't triggered, and the dehumidifier was running (and connection between the cord and the extension cord was submerged).
Basically all the water than had been leaking and had been pumped out, combined with the meltwater from the two ft of snow we got a few weeks ago and whatever precipitation since, was just seeping back in. The pump spits the water out basically right on the other side of the foundation so it filters right back in, and the pump stopped overnight.
So that was cool.