First, nobody is "too good" for anyone. They may want other things in their life that are different than you may want, say like they're really into socializing and you aren't, but nobody is "too good". There are plenty of "opposites attract" stories out there. I remember reading about a woman, a member of Mensa with PhD who had been married to a garage mechanic for 20 years (at that time).
Second, though not mentioned in the OP, is the concept of a "soulmate" - utter garbage. The idea that there is one perfect person in the world for you is insane. Ask most people to describe their "soulmate" and they'll immediately go into physical characteristics, which have nothing to do with one's soul. What if it turned out that, no matter your sexual orientation, your absolute "soulmate" was some 70 yr old man in Mongolia who you are never destined meet?