Jump to content
UnevenEdge

What Anime Are You Watching Right Now?


BUU8800

Recommended Posts

FMA 4-7

Hard to believe Mustang has the same VA in Brotherhood and the OG because here he sounds very... "light" I guess is the word.

Also what I can gather from bouncing off of B's pilot to this is that it works! BUT I did notice that the dialogue for that one Brotherhood episode felt very shonen-y and, dare I say, "kiddy" compared to that of these episodes in the OG. It's almost like comparing Marvel fare to Ingmar Bergman.

That and you're forced get to hear the introductory "HE'S THE FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST" twice. :LithiumSmileyIndifferent:

Edited by MasqueradeOverture
Link to comment
Share on other sites

FMA 8-12

I have a weird nostalgia for the Barry The Butcher episode (it was the 1st episode of FMA I randomly came upon on AS in the mid-00's). Also don't hate the Justin Cook fake-Elrics 2-parter as much as a lot of people do.

General observations: Are the backgrounds traditional matte paintings? Wouldn't be surprised if in '03 studios were doing parts of production the old-fashioned way while digitally painting the characters in front of that. Also noticing a decent amount of tape hiss whenever a child actor speaks (as if they were recorded with a different [possibly analog] set up outside of Funi's studio or something due to child labor laws).

EDIT: OH BOY. Found a tragic flaw in my approach to use Brotherhood's 1st episode as a pilot to my endeavors here and it's FUCKING HUGHES [In Brotherhood, the Elrics meet him right before Leore, whereas they've known each other for at least 3 years at that point in FMA 03].

This is gonna eat at me but whatever. Not splicing in any other Brotherhood episodes until I bounce off of FMA.

Edited by MasqueradeOverture
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

FMA 13-25 / Brotherhood 9-10

Well I ruined the illusion of a seamless transition LOL it looks like both

Spoiler

Barry The Chopper dies and '03 Femme-Sloth comes in at episode 24. RIGHT BEFORE HUGHES CROAKS. AND I LIKE HIS DEATH SO MUCH BETTER IN THE ORIGINAL. WHOOPTIE FUCK.

Then when Hughes DOES kick the bucket and the boys / Winry are on the train, Ed mentions on the way to Rush Valley they're gonna find Scar at an Ishval camp. THIS. DOES. NOT. HAPPEN. IN. BROTHERHOOD.

So no, as much as I hate to say it, you can't jump from "The Event" into Brotherhood as too much '03 original stuff is in play already. However, aside from The Secretary / Juliette Douglas just hanging out in the background with no follow up, you can seamlessly jump into Brotherhood right after Lab 5 (so basically go from FMA 22 to Brotherhood 9).

That said, I forgot how cartoony and lame Brotherhood can be. "The Event" holds no weight and gravitas, and neither does Basque's talk with Ed & the subsequent tension between the brothers. I remember the humor calming itself down at a certain point, but this is really rough.

EDIT: Went back and watched FMA 25 with the commentary track to wash the taste out of my mouth. To hell with the inconsistencies, back to our regularly scheduled programming.

Edited by MasqueradeOverture
Link to comment
Share on other sites

FMA 29 - 39

The anime original stuff with Wrath and Greed up to episode 34 is GREAT. There's a very Southern Gothic vibe with the Dante mansion that I heavily mess with. 

Unfortunately, 35 - 39 feels like a lull. It's dragging now -- And while there's moments with Winry and Mustang that feel of narrative significance, something feels off. When the Homunculi are spending their time plotting in dive bars, the threat feels much smaller than it should. Not only that, but the Ishval stuff is becoming a bore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gamera Rebirth 2-3.

Apparently this is what the director wanted to do with the Godzilla trilogy before he was told by Toho they didn’t want something they directly competed with the Legendary films, but the monster brawls fit quite well with Gamera as a more heroic kaiju given his own filmography even in the famous Heisei trilogy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FMA Brotherhood 21 - 34

Oh wow the incompatibility between the two series runs deeper than I thought.

Spoiler

- The Elrics had no idea Scar had a tatoo until like 20-something episodes into Brotherhood. However, Ed rips Scar's sleeve and sees it in episode 6 of the '03 series.

- Mustang is revealed to kill Winry's parents in '03. Scar kills them in Brotherhood.

- Mustang never heard of Dr. Marcoh until Braeda gives him a note informing him of his existence. Mustang and Marcoh meet in person WAY earlier in '03.

- Winry delivering a baby in Rush Valley is rendered redundant since Ed & Al help with Gracia Hughes' birth in '03.

- The story of Scar's brother losing his dick in the transmutation of his dead gf in '03 does, in zero ways, mesh with Brotherhood's version of the story.

- The person who triggered the Ishallan war was Envy disguised as an Aryan dude, a direct contradiction to '03's cause being a bullet from Juliet Douglas.

- Speaking of Ishval, Ed mentioning learning about the Ishval war for the first time through Hawkeye doesn’t work with Marcoh telling the boys about it early in the '03 series.

It would take an absolute madman to try to edit this together into one chimera cut.

Oh wait a minute... image.png.a5e20cdc57037b80873207efdd209397.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...