Wait, so you actually use your email to log in?????
I have quite the opposite problem......I have an alt and I changed the password because I had let someone borrow the account for a while......I tried to log into it but couldn't remember the password, so I wanted to reset it, but can't remember which email I used to get the reset key.
I mean I could figure it out eventually, but I was stoned and stopped caring after that. Point is, I use my SN to log in.