Mister @Top Gun has some excellent recommendations! I would especially second My Hero Academia because it is just such a fantastic show.
It seems like you’ve got a few different genres you enjoy so I’ll just toss a couple out here for your consideration:
- if you want something a little dark and unusual, I love Madoka Magica. It takes the whole magical girl theme and puts a big twist on it that really results in some next level mind duckery.
- I truly adore Konosuba, but have you tried any other shows in the “stuck in a game” genre? Log Horizon is a great one if you’re looking for something thoughtful and immersive. (Not as cheeky, but still a favorite.) Or, if you’re looking for shows that have a similar sense of humor to Konosuba, you might find you enjoy something like Heaven’s Lost Property.
- You might like Deadman Wonderland based on some of the other shows you’ve watched. Similarly, Prison School is a really offbeat dystopian show and it’s pretty strange but I like it. (The live action is on Funimation and that’s worth watching too, if you like the series!)
- If you liked TTGL and Kill la Kill, check out Punch Line. It uses some of the same production staff members as these other shows and I found it to be similarly crazy and offbeat. The plot is sort of a funny sci-fi mixed with paranormal vibe.
- Other shows that I like and would rec in general: Ghost in the Shell, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Ouran High School Host Club, and Rage of Bahamut.
